Growing up transgender in the 60′s, in a rather conservative, strict family, and as a Reformed Presbyterian (to this day, I have no idea what we were reforming) was pretty difficult and lonely. I guess I had always felt a bit disconnected from everyone around me. I never really understood them and they seemed to not really understand me. I think because of this, I never really seemed to know how to interact with others. This included my own family.
As I was growing up and becoming more aware that I was different and as I started to have these strange feelings about how I felt, well, wrong, I became more withdrawn, more introverted, shyer. My mom loves to tell everyone the story of how I had to repeat Kindergarten.
Doesn’t she realize how embarrassing it is to repeat Kindergarten?
Well, I’m not going to go into all of the details that led up to my being held back, but the short of it is that for that entire first year in this class, I did not say one single word in that school. Not a peep! Looking at the whole back story and all of the sub-plots that played into the decision to keep me back, it would seem that any of these would be sufficient to keep me there. However, looking back at it, from nearly 45 years into the future and remembering little tiny snippets from that year, I know that even at the tender age of 5 I knew that I somehow didn’t fit in. No, I wasn’t one of those lucky (or unlucky) kids that knew she was born into the wrong body at that young age. It would take a while longer for me to start suspecting something along those lines.
As I grew into my young adolescence, things started becoming even more confusing for me. For some reason by the age of 8 or 9 I started becoming more and more drawn to, or obsessed with, the fact that my sister and mother dressed very differently than I did. The way they looked seemed to be more desirable to me than the ugly and uncomfortable clothes that I had to wear, the ones that were like my brother’s. In fact sometimes they were the very same clothes my brother wore. Being 11 months older than me, I often got to wear what he had just barely outgrew, or we would just have the same clothes (I don’t really remember any more than I hated those clothes – it was the 60′s after all). It got to the point that I would start looking through the laundry and pondering the contents, wondering at how much softer and nicer those things were.
What are you doing?
That was the question I got when my mom came home, unexpectedly early, the first time I tried on a pair of red cotton panties (honestly not sure if they were my mom’s or sister’s). I replied that I didn’t know. Which was a perfectly honest answer, because I had no clue beyond it just felt right. How long have you been doing this? Well being the first time actually wearing them, I answered honestly. At that point, mom told me not to ever let her catch me doing that again. She never has to this day.
From that time on, things really began to get difficult inside my head, I was confused about why I felt so strongly compelled to wear girl’s/women’s clothing. According to everything everyone told me, I was a boy and boys don’t do that. Now it would be a number of years later before I would get to see for certain why exactly everyone told me I was a boy and not a girl. Up till that day of reckoning, I had held out some kind of hope that I might yet become a girl. That thought nagged at me for decades. I knew that I wanted to be a girl and not a boy, but I also knew instinctively that I needed to keep that a secret, because no one would understand and I didn’t want to end up locked away in a mental hospital or worse. I had to keep this secret to myself. I had to also try to learn why I was this freak. As time went on, I became very quiet and withdrawn, I had very few friends growing up, I really could not relate to my brother or my sister or my mother even. As I got older and was expected to participate in conversations with other people, I tended to just sit on the sidelines and try to become invisible. I spent all of this time sitting there listening to everything I could hear. I was trying to understand the dynamics of conversation, what people said and talked about and tried to figure out why they talked about what they were talking about. Adults were always more interesting to listen to than the kids my age. I was expected to play with the other boys and do boy things, which never felt right to me.
Girl Friends
I had always had a much easier time relating to and understanding girls. I had friends who were girls, of course they never knew my secret – no one did. I think the girls always felt something about me was different than the other boys, I was easier to understand and I seemed to understand them and was more interested in what they were doing than I was in the boys activities. But as I got to that age when boys were supposed to become interested in girls and chasing them, dating them, I retreated further and further into my shell, building stronger defenses to keep my secret hidden away, even so far as trying to keep it away from myself. I am and always have been attracted to girls/women, but it had always gone far beyond what I knew the other guys felt. I also become paralyzingly shy around the girls that I was interested in. I could not ask them out, I had no idea how to ask a girl out, it also didn’t feel right to. I made hundreds of attempts at asking out those I was attracted to and every single last one of them turned me down. Yeah, a few of them just laughed in my face or looked me up and down with a disgusted look on their face like I had just asked them to do something extremely offensive. But, by far, I would get the your a nice guy, I just want to be friends, you’ll make some girl a perfect husband someday, but not me, or any of a hundred variations on that theme. It wouldn’t be until I was 42 that I would finally have a date – she asked me out. We dated for less than a month before she broke it off because she believed I was gay. I wasn’t (exactly), I still had no idea that I was a transsexual lesbian, so I guess she was half right.
What is this Transalienation?
Oh, right, that is where I was going… A lot of us who grew up as transsexuals or transgender (I guess) and never really understood what our problem was till later in life, seem to have this feeling of being alienated or isolated within ourselves. We seem to know that something is wrong and that it is something that is not the kind of thing you talk to people about, because it is just that wrong. It seems as though there is no one in our lives who appear to feel the same way, therefore we are ‘freakish’, wrong in some way. I have had many friends over the years that would ask me if I was an alien. They were apparently serious. They knew that I was nothing like anyone else they had ever met and could not understand me at all and I really had no capacity to really understand them to any degree – I had to be an alien. I had been asked that enough times that I had begun to wonder if in fact I was an alien.
Two of the people I should have understood best and who should have been able to understand me, were the two people that I alienated myself from the most. I’m referring to my own flesh and blood, my brother and sister. Granted my sister is six years older than me, so growing up she was into infinitely different things than I was supposed to be. But my brother was less than a year different, though to look at us together you would think we were entirely different beings. As the years drifted past, we drifted further apart. My brother and I have scarcely talked in the past 30 years. If we see each other once a year at this point in life, that is a big deal. The last time I saw him was last October – he was working here in Atlanta and I got to talk to him a few minutes. My sister on the other hand, it has been perhaps 20 years since I have ‘spoken’ to her. Even the times I spent at her house on holidays and such, I rarely ever spoke – unless it was to answer a question or maybe even ask one. I was never comfortable around them.
Hopefully that is now in the past, or will soon be. This week, I got up the nerve and the inspiration to write each of them a letter. I let them each know a little bit of the pain I have been going through and some glimpse into why they have not been able to know me. The short of that is that I didn’t know who I was. To be honest I had no idea what to expect from either of them, I fully deserved to be ignored and laughed at. But, I was optimistic and hopeful that perhaps now I would be able to allow my siblings to finally get to know me and me to know them. I fully expected to not hear from them for a week or more, if ever. I fully expected them to talk to one another to figure out how to respond. I can honestly say that I didn’t expect either of them to reply within a day and to do so with such beautifully written responses. Both letters brought me to tears. I was so moved and felt a little ashamed that I let the better part of 49 years go by without being able to know them. Hopefully now, I can make amends to that and finally share my SELF with them. Of course I’m sure neither of them would have ever thought that they would all of a sudden have a 49-year-old baby sister. HAHA!
The first step has been made. First contact. Now it is up to me to keep them in the loop, not shrink away into the corner and expect them to come to me. I am so happy right now and feel so blessed to have found my siblings to be warm and loving people after so long. I love you D & D. <3